Monday, October 29, 2012
"Growth Strategies" and the IMF
In his famous journal article Growth Strategies, Dani Rodrik examines why there has been so much discrepancy between the growth of developed nations and developing nations. Contrary to what Robert Solow predicted, countries were not converging to the same growth levels and the gap between developed and developing nations is becoming bigger. After analyzing the different growth stories of East-Asian countries, Africa and Latin America, Rodrik finds that what set the East-Asian countries aside from the other developing countries was how they applied unorthodox, context specific growth policies. Whereas in Latin American, countries that throughout much of the 90s were the 'poster' child of the Washington Consensus failed at closing this gap.
Last Thursday (10/25/2012), Professor Smitka gave a lecture about the IMF, he introduced us to a case study about Brazil and Jamaica. During this presentation, I was shocked to find out the little consideration that the IMF seems to have toward the cultural and social characteristics of the country they are working with. This got me thinking, why would such an important institution as the IMF not take into account what economic evidence suggests regarding economic growth? Historically, policies implemented by the IMF (expansionary fiscal contraction) have not resulted in optimal outcomes, then again, why would the IMF not have research that allows them to implement context specific policies as Rodrik suggests and the East-Asian countries did?
It is a well-known fact that there is "no silver bullet for economic development", then why does the IMF projects the image that austerity is that silver bullet? As I mentioned in one of my earlier posts, there is a serious need for an institutional reform within this organization. The more I read about it, the more skeptical I become about the true goal of the IMF and I ask myself if high dependance theory is an actual concern that we should have.
Finally, how would the reputation of the IMF change if the policies they implement become more context specific? What would happen if the IMF chooses a different policy set instead of austerity? Driving an economy to the ground is not the only way in which a country can increase its competitiveness.
Thursday, October 25, 2012
Off-shoring jobs from China?
During our class discussions we have extensively covered job off-shoring and how China has become a leader in manufacturing. However, during the last couple of years, rising wages made several people and organizations skeptical about the capabilities that China has as a nation to keep gaining terrain on the manufacturing front. This skepticism grew so much, that this week The Economist selected this topic as one of their debate issues. However, the question The Economist poses is not about China's ability to be a manufacturing leader. Instead, what they debate is whether or not manufacturing will return to the West. I am very much interested in seeing how this discussion progresses as time goes by and what their final verdict is.
Monday, October 22, 2012
Middle Class Spending in Emerging Markets
Since the financial crush of 2008, economists and famous magazines such as The Economist believed that Europe and the US were not going to be able to re-ignite economic growth and that the key to successfully put an end to the depression was a responsibility that emerging markets should complete. It is widely believed that the only way in which they could possibly achieve this was by increasing middle class spending. The only problem was that in many of these countries the middle class was negligible.
This morning, Beyond Brics, a FT blog, posted a very interesting chart that follows middle class spending in China, Brazil, India, Russia and Mexico. I find the results extremely optimistic.
As we can see above, the middle class in all 5 countries has experienced an improvement in all three dimensions. As it can be seen, Brazil, Mexico and India have experienced some sort of stagnation in the average annual middle class income (OECD definition of middle class: someone who earns $10 to $100 dollars per day), not a dramatic increase in the proportion of the middle class people and a relative strong increase in middle class spending. What happened in Russia and India for the last 12 years is surprising. Russia has experienced not only a significant increase in the average income, but a surprising rise in the proportion of the population that are now middle class people. Regarding China, the increase of middle class spending is astonishing. Also, it is surprising to see an approximate ~20% growth in the proportion of middle class people.
Despite that these results are extremely positive, I grow hesitant about emerging markets economies. It is a well known fact that high levels of growth are not only hard to sustain but they also result in an overheated economy.
This morning, Beyond Brics, a FT blog, posted a very interesting chart that follows middle class spending in China, Brazil, India, Russia and Mexico. I find the results extremely optimistic.
![]() |
| Source: FT Blog Beyond Brics. |
Despite that these results are extremely positive, I grow hesitant about emerging markets economies. It is a well known fact that high levels of growth are not only hard to sustain but they also result in an overheated economy.
Monday, October 15, 2012
Krugman's thoughts on Argentina
As I read Krugman's book The Return of Depression Economics I can't resist myself to comment about the way that Krugman describes Argentina after the Great Depression. Quoting him:
"Emergency control on foreign exchange became nightmarish complex set of regulations that discouraged enterprise and fostered corruption. Temporary limitation on imports became permanent barriers behind which astonishingly inefficient industries survived. Nationalized enterprises become sinks for public founds..."Does this sounds familiar? To me it just sounds to Cristina Fernandez government in 2012. Every single one of these were implemented in Argentina this year.
Reshaping Economics?
Today they awarded the 2012 Nobel Prize in Economics to Lloyd Shapley and Alvin Roth for their work on match making theory. One of the main goals of economics is to study "markets where prices adjust so that demand equals supply". However, there are certain markets where prices do not adjust and it is either impossible or ethically wrong to allocate resources through price mechanisms (eg. organ donor markets). Given that in this type of markets prices, which have proven to be an excellent match making instrument, can't be used, the question is how do you create a stable match between supply and demand? That's when their work comes in to reshape Economics.
Lloyd Shapley contributed to their work mainly from a theoretical standpoint. What he argues is that if individuals are rational and they engage in simple, unrestricted mutual trade, then the outcome should be efficient (everyone is satisfied with their pairing). Lloyd created an algorithm that "always lead to stable matching."
Roth, set out to test and improve this algorithm by working together with the National Resident Matching Program. His worked not only solved for the existing manipulation problem in Shapley's work, but it also allows the match making of over 20,000 positions per year. In addition, both Roth and Shapley have applied their algorithms to markets such as high-schools and students, kidneys and patients.
Not surprisingly, both authors are currently working in expanding their algorithms and including prices in them. What would the ramifications of creating such algorithm be? If we find a substitute for prices that take into account our individual preferences would be reach a Pareto optimal point? If not, their work has offered great insight to markets where matching supply and demand was previously a problem.
Lloyd Shapley contributed to their work mainly from a theoretical standpoint. What he argues is that if individuals are rational and they engage in simple, unrestricted mutual trade, then the outcome should be efficient (everyone is satisfied with their pairing). Lloyd created an algorithm that "always lead to stable matching."
Roth, set out to test and improve this algorithm by working together with the National Resident Matching Program. His worked not only solved for the existing manipulation problem in Shapley's work, but it also allows the match making of over 20,000 positions per year. In addition, both Roth and Shapley have applied their algorithms to markets such as high-schools and students, kidneys and patients.
Not surprisingly, both authors are currently working in expanding their algorithms and including prices in them. What would the ramifications of creating such algorithm be? If we find a substitute for prices that take into account our individual preferences would be reach a Pareto optimal point? If not, their work has offered great insight to markets where matching supply and demand was previously a problem.
Thursday, October 4, 2012
The "Chinnese Dream"
Interesting article by Thomas Friedman on the rapid growth the Chinese economy is experimenting and why it my be prone to fail. According to Friedman all China needs to sustain this growth is the equivalent of "big car, big house and Big Macs for all" but subject to Chinese culture.
Monday, October 1, 2012
Migration Barriers and Tiebout's Model (1st Draft)
Last Thursday (09/27/2012) in our International Political Economy class we talked about spillover effects generated by trade. This discussion spur some thoughts regarding how would these spillover effects change if we imagine a world like the one that Tiebout described in 1956.
Tiebout's model is mostly used to describe club theory and how public goods can actually fix "market type solution" as Samuelson called them. In this world, people "vote with their feet"; this means that individuals travel from club to club until they find their preferred one and stay in that one. Basically, there are no migration barriers, individuals face no cost in traveling and they allocate themselves strategically to maximize their utility.
In Tiebout's model, we assume a society composed of different clubs that are non rival and exclusive. When we say that a good is non-rival, we mean that an individual can consume as much as they want without affecting other individuals consumption level (eg. air television). By exclusive, we mean that people that do not pay for the good can not consume it, thus there is no free-rider problem. In addition to this semi-public good world, Tiebout assumes that:
If any of these where to be true, then, what would happen with labor? Where would high-skilled labor end up? Where would low-skilled labor migrate to? What about capital? Would countries converge to the same steady states growth levels as Solow predicted? Would we be able to reach world equality?
At a first glance, it seems that capital would flow to those places where the returns are high. Therefore, capitalists, will allocate in places such as Africa, Latin America and Asia. Following the same line of thought, low-skill workers, will go where the return to labor are higher, thus moving to places such as Europe and the United States. Following the same behavioral pattern as low-skill workers, high-skill workers will also migrate to places where their wages are high. If we believe in the Invisible Hand of economics, then we can expect capital and labor to flow freely around the world until the returns of both variables equal. Yet, there is one economic factor and one social factor that complicates the picture: land and culture.
Why do land and culture stain this hypotheses? First, land complicates this free migration world because it is an exogenous variable. Despite that capital and labor are believed to be exogenous variables too, in this model they are not. A society can determine the amount of capital that each club will have. However, a given club can't determine the return on their land. Therefore, labor will now depend on the return of land and the return on capital. Low-skill labor, will move to places like the United States or Europe if:
Mancur Olsen said that the world should adopt a nation-state system with many resemblances to the one I just described. I wonder to what extent Olsen had club theroy in mind when he mentioned this.
Tiebout's model is mostly used to describe club theory and how public goods can actually fix "market type solution" as Samuelson called them. In this world, people "vote with their feet"; this means that individuals travel from club to club until they find their preferred one and stay in that one. Basically, there are no migration barriers, individuals face no cost in traveling and they allocate themselves strategically to maximize their utility.
In Tiebout's model, we assume a society composed of different clubs that are non rival and exclusive. When we say that a good is non-rival, we mean that an individual can consume as much as they want without affecting other individuals consumption level (eg. air television). By exclusive, we mean that people that do not pay for the good can not consume it, thus there is no free-rider problem. In addition to this semi-public good world, Tiebout assumes that:
- Consumers are free to choose where they live
- Complete information.
- Many communities to choose from.
- Commuting is not an issue.
- No spillover in terms of benefits/costs from one community to the next.
- An optimal city size exist.
- Communities try to achieve "optimal size".
- Communities are rational and try to keep the public 'bad' consumers away.
If any of these where to be true, then, what would happen with labor? Where would high-skilled labor end up? Where would low-skilled labor migrate to? What about capital? Would countries converge to the same steady states growth levels as Solow predicted? Would we be able to reach world equality?
At a first glance, it seems that capital would flow to those places where the returns are high. Therefore, capitalists, will allocate in places such as Africa, Latin America and Asia. Following the same line of thought, low-skill workers, will go where the return to labor are higher, thus moving to places such as Europe and the United States. Following the same behavioral pattern as low-skill workers, high-skill workers will also migrate to places where their wages are high. If we believe in the Invisible Hand of economics, then we can expect capital and labor to flow freely around the world until the returns of both variables equal. Yet, there is one economic factor and one social factor that complicates the picture: land and culture.
Why do land and culture stain this hypotheses? First, land complicates this free migration world because it is an exogenous variable. Despite that capital and labor are believed to be exogenous variables too, in this model they are not. A society can determine the amount of capital that each club will have. However, a given club can't determine the return on their land. Therefore, labor will now depend on the return of land and the return on capital. Low-skill labor, will move to places like the United States or Europe if:
- Return on land + Return on labor in the US or Europe is greater than the return of land + return on labor in club i.
Mancur Olsen said that the world should adopt a nation-state system with many resemblances to the one I just described. I wonder to what extent Olsen had club theroy in mind when he mentioned this.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
