No doubt investors want nothing to do with Argentina."El único lugar de América donde no hay golpes es en Estados Unidos, y eso es porque no hay ninguna embajada americana" (The only place in the Americas where there are no coups is in the United States because theres no American Embassy)
Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Where are your manners Mrs. President?
Cristina Kirchner address a group of students at Georgetown University today. Staying loyal to her style she was condescending, know it all and aggressive. She did not only attacked the IMF but also questioned the U.S. statistics and supported Chavez. My favorite, this one:
Tuesday, September 25, 2012
FTSE Equity Index Ranking
This month the FTSE Group recently released their famous "FTSE Equity Index Series Classification'. The goal of this report is to classify equity markets into different categories so that investors have a insightful information.
The classification of countries goes from:
Supporting what I mentioned regarding Argentina in my previous post; it comes as no surprise that they are considering to remove it from the Index. I believe that reasons to further develop why this is happening are not required.
The report had a couple of shocking surprises. First, Greece is classified as developed and they are just now considering a downgrade. I find it surprising because Greece has already requested two bailouts and have several austerity measures in place. Greece is constantly becoming more insolvent and the risk of a default increases. Yet, they are a developed equity index? As I mentioned last time, Krugman and other suggested that Greece should follow Argentina's footsteps in 2001. However, will pretty beaches and fun parties provide a exogenous shock sufficient enough to revive their economy after default? I seriously doubt it. Along this same lines you can find any other PIGS country. However, there are no expectations of a downgrade for the other countries.On the opposite, countries such as Chile, Colombia, Philippines and Russia still have a Secondary Emerging rating.
It is often said that it is important to learn from our mistakes. It seems to me that financial institutions are to stubborn to learn from 2008. Informational asymmetries can have a severe impact on our economy and unless governments decide to regulate these institutions better we will be doomed to keep keep bursting new bubbles. In 1776, a time when financial markets were nowhere near as complex as today, Adam Smith wrote about the importance of regulating the financial industry.
The classification of countries goes from:
- Developed
- Advance Emerging
- Secondary Emerging
- Frontier
Supporting what I mentioned regarding Argentina in my previous post; it comes as no surprise that they are considering to remove it from the Index. I believe that reasons to further develop why this is happening are not required.
The report had a couple of shocking surprises. First, Greece is classified as developed and they are just now considering a downgrade. I find it surprising because Greece has already requested two bailouts and have several austerity measures in place. Greece is constantly becoming more insolvent and the risk of a default increases. Yet, they are a developed equity index? As I mentioned last time, Krugman and other suggested that Greece should follow Argentina's footsteps in 2001. However, will pretty beaches and fun parties provide a exogenous shock sufficient enough to revive their economy after default? I seriously doubt it. Along this same lines you can find any other PIGS country. However, there are no expectations of a downgrade for the other countries.On the opposite, countries such as Chile, Colombia, Philippines and Russia still have a Secondary Emerging rating.
It is often said that it is important to learn from our mistakes. It seems to me that financial institutions are to stubborn to learn from 2008. Informational asymmetries can have a severe impact on our economy and unless governments decide to regulate these institutions better we will be doomed to keep keep bursting new bubbles. In 1776, a time when financial markets were nowhere near as complex as today, Adam Smith wrote about the importance of regulating the financial industry.
Wednesday, September 19, 2012
The Argentine "Miracle"
In my last post, I attempted to provide some detail on the biggest challenge that world leaders in the international political economy spectrum face in the XXI century. As I mentioned on Monday, September the 17 of 2012, I believe that the biggest challenge is state capitalism. Today, I want to revise my previous post and through a case study of Argentina, analyze if state capitalism is actually a big threat to world leaders.
Pierpaolo Barbieri, a fellow at Harvard Kennedy School, on August 8, 2012 wrote an article on the Wall Street Journal an article about Argentina and the political atrocities the Kirchner have done since their rise in 2003. Mr. Barbieri smarty calls it Crony Capitalism, he does so, because since they been in power, the Kirchner have been too concerned with making their friends better off and society worse off.
The Kirchners came to power in 2003 after wining the elections against Carlos Menem. Following, what came to be known as the biggest default in history (~$132bn), Argentina experienced rapid growth levels, mainly due to increase demand of soybeans from China. This exogenous increase in demand, allowed the Kirchner to be marked as responsible forgetting Argentina out from its crises. Rest assured, that the rapid growth that Argentina experienced has nothing to do with the policies that the Kirchners' established.
Many renowned economists such as Paul Krugman and Joseph Stiglitz have publicly endorsed Argentina's success story. Does that mean the Kirchner have been successful with their crony and protectionist policies? No, both Krugman and Stiglitz fail to go beyond the data; they simply look at GDP and some main economic indicators. Though they are both of them some of the most brilliant minds in the field, they fail at studying the living experience Argentinians have to put up with. Mr. Barbieri does a great job at this.
Just to summarize the main policies that Mr. Barbieri describes:
Looking at the broader image and other countries in Latin America, it can be concluded that Argentina has wasted an opportunity to climb up the ladder of development that Brazil and Chile climbed when they had the chance.At least, society decided to bring back the famous or infamous cacerolazo of 2001. The question now, is how do we get Argentina out of this mess? With few or none trustworthy politicians and weak institutions, it is going to be a hard task. On a worldwide spectrum, how can leaders in the developed world prevent leaders in the developing world to adopt state capitalism?
Pierpaolo Barbieri, a fellow at Harvard Kennedy School, on August 8, 2012 wrote an article on the Wall Street Journal an article about Argentina and the political atrocities the Kirchner have done since their rise in 2003. Mr. Barbieri smarty calls it Crony Capitalism, he does so, because since they been in power, the Kirchner have been too concerned with making their friends better off and society worse off.
The Kirchners came to power in 2003 after wining the elections against Carlos Menem. Following, what came to be known as the biggest default in history (~$132bn), Argentina experienced rapid growth levels, mainly due to increase demand of soybeans from China. This exogenous increase in demand, allowed the Kirchner to be marked as responsible forgetting Argentina out from its crises. Rest assured, that the rapid growth that Argentina experienced has nothing to do with the policies that the Kirchners' established.
Many renowned economists such as Paul Krugman and Joseph Stiglitz have publicly endorsed Argentina's success story. Does that mean the Kirchner have been successful with their crony and protectionist policies? No, both Krugman and Stiglitz fail to go beyond the data; they simply look at GDP and some main economic indicators. Though they are both of them some of the most brilliant minds in the field, they fail at studying the living experience Argentinians have to put up with. Mr. Barbieri does a great job at this.
Just to summarize the main policies that Mr. Barbieri describes:
- Decreased independence of institutions:
- Destroyed central bank's independence from government.
- Manipulated the national statistics agency to report lower inflation rates.
- Severe currency and trade controls.
- Nationalized private pensions
- Seized large private companies.
- Lack of property rights and increased crime rates.
Looking at the broader image and other countries in Latin America, it can be concluded that Argentina has wasted an opportunity to climb up the ladder of development that Brazil and Chile climbed when they had the chance.At least, society decided to bring back the famous or infamous cacerolazo of 2001. The question now, is how do we get Argentina out of this mess? With few or none trustworthy politicians and weak institutions, it is going to be a hard task. On a worldwide spectrum, how can leaders in the developed world prevent leaders in the developing world to adopt state capitalism?
Monday, September 17, 2012
A look Ahead
On Monday, September 15, 2008,Lehman Brothers filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy. Ever since then, world leaders have been questioning the effectiveness of capitalism and democracy as the best organizational system for a country. Developing countries have been seeking alternate systems that might facilitate a shorter path towards economic growth. What came to be known as the Great Recession posed a new challenge for the leading actors in the international political economy of the 21st Century. These actors, are now responsible to determine if capitalism is the preferred political and economic system for a country.
After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Francis Fukuyama wrote "The end of History?". In this very renowned essay, Fukuyama questioned that since capitalism had triumphed over communism we had reached the end of history:
Finally, the other challenger of capitalism is something that has been named state-capitalism. Alwyn Young wrote about "The Tyranny of Numbers: Confronting the Statistical Realities of the East Asian Growth Experience". In this paper he deeply studied the growth that the newly industrialized countries experienced from 1966 to 1991. Despite of the significant economic theory finding that this paper haves, it provides an excellent perspective of state-capitalism, a political and economic model for the last couple of years China has its main advocate.The sudden success story of China has raised several questions about the advantages of a state controlled economy with certain level of openness to the world markets. However, the effectiveness and the level of development that state-capitalism facilitates is under the eyes of critics given that some people remain skeptical of China's success and expect a rapid collapse due to an over-heated economy.
So the leaders of the international political economy are faced with an exciting and interesting challenge. We are currently living on the brink of transitioning to a new political-economic system. Whether we make this transition or no, is yet to be determined; and it is largely up to the hands of leaders in the developed world to protect the collapse of free-market capitalism.
Soon we will find out if Winston Churchill was right when he said: "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time."
After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Francis Fukuyama wrote "The end of History?". In this very renowned essay, Fukuyama questioned that since capitalism had triumphed over communism we had reached the end of history:
"HAVE WE in fact reached the end of history? Are there, in other words, any fundamental "contradictions" in human life that cannot be resolved in the context of modern liberalism, that would be resolvable by an alternative political-economic structure?"Observing the events that the world has experienced since Fukuyams's essay (published during the Summer of 1989), it can easily be said that we are nowhere close to "the end of history". One of the main events that prove the invalidity of this statement occurred in 1999 when the European Union adopted the Euro. This gave rise to new 'political-economic structure' that challenges capitalism. The effectiveness of this system is now under pressured due to the European Debt Crises. The future of this system is yet to be determined. The EU leaders seem to be willing to do what is necessary to save the system and see it succeed. The ECB recently announced and unlimited bond-buying plan that should help the EU to come out of its crisis.
Finally, the other challenger of capitalism is something that has been named state-capitalism. Alwyn Young wrote about "The Tyranny of Numbers: Confronting the Statistical Realities of the East Asian Growth Experience". In this paper he deeply studied the growth that the newly industrialized countries experienced from 1966 to 1991. Despite of the significant economic theory finding that this paper haves, it provides an excellent perspective of state-capitalism, a political and economic model for the last couple of years China has its main advocate.The sudden success story of China has raised several questions about the advantages of a state controlled economy with certain level of openness to the world markets. However, the effectiveness and the level of development that state-capitalism facilitates is under the eyes of critics given that some people remain skeptical of China's success and expect a rapid collapse due to an over-heated economy.
So the leaders of the international political economy are faced with an exciting and interesting challenge. We are currently living on the brink of transitioning to a new political-economic system. Whether we make this transition or no, is yet to be determined; and it is largely up to the hands of leaders in the developed world to protect the collapse of free-market capitalism.
Soon we will find out if Winston Churchill was right when he said: "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time."
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
Time for an Institutional Reform?
Once again a developing nation has attacked the International Monetary Fund. Viktor Orbán, Hungrary's prime minister stated on Monday that its country did not need any further action from the IMF despite of the current crises its country is suffering.
For the last several years, the IMF reputation within the developing world has been drastically diminished - specially throughout Latin America. These countries, have not only attacked the role of the IMF but also challenged it. Several countries went as far as breaking all relations they had with the organization.
As the IMF reputation diminishes and developing nations tend to label this institution as the enemy of economic growth; I start to wonder if it is time to change the ways of the institution. I like to believe that the IMF sole goal is to "work to foster global monetary cooperation, secure financial stability, facilitate international trade, promote high employment and sustainable economic growth, and reduce poverty around the world."
However, as more developing nations line up against this and other institutions I find it hard to believe that the IMF its doing its job right. Can it be that institutions such as this one and the World Bank are being used as an instrument for neo-imperialism? Should we modify its internal structure so that they actually work to achieve their mission statement? Also, lets not forget about this year's controversial World Bank presidential elections.
For the last several years, the IMF reputation within the developing world has been drastically diminished - specially throughout Latin America. These countries, have not only attacked the role of the IMF but also challenged it. Several countries went as far as breaking all relations they had with the organization.
As the IMF reputation diminishes and developing nations tend to label this institution as the enemy of economic growth; I start to wonder if it is time to change the ways of the institution. I like to believe that the IMF sole goal is to "work to foster global monetary cooperation, secure financial stability, facilitate international trade, promote high employment and sustainable economic growth, and reduce poverty around the world."
However, as more developing nations line up against this and other institutions I find it hard to believe that the IMF its doing its job right. Can it be that institutions such as this one and the World Bank are being used as an instrument for neo-imperialism? Should we modify its internal structure so that they actually work to achieve their mission statement? Also, lets not forget about this year's controversial World Bank presidential elections.
Sunday, September 9, 2012
"Protectionist" Latin America?
'Beyond Brics', a Financial Times blog that specializes in Emerging Markets has recently posted two interesting articles about Brazil's and Argentina's trade policies.
Economic theory and evidence from research indicates that in order for a developing nation to be able to overcome poverty and inequality it is necessary to make an initial transition from the agricultural industry to the manufacturing and services industry (Barry Eichengreen, 2007). Therefore, both countries seem to be in favor of establishing protectionist trade policies that will spur the manufacturing industry.
Though Brazil tax import policies have been quite volatile throughout the 2012 fiscal year, it can be said with certainty that they lean towards protectionism rather than free-trade. Yet, Brazil has somehow managed to avoid complains in the WTO and project the image of a pro-liberal and free trade country; an image that its neighboring country, Argentina, has failed to project to the World.
With that in mind, why do both countries project such a different image to the world? Why do Brazil's trade policies are more accepted than Argentina's trade policies? After all, both policies attempt to reach the same goal: develop their own manufacturer industry.
Economic theory and evidence from research indicates that in order for a developing nation to be able to overcome poverty and inequality it is necessary to make an initial transition from the agricultural industry to the manufacturing and services industry (Barry Eichengreen, 2007). Therefore, both countries seem to be in favor of establishing protectionist trade policies that will spur the manufacturing industry.
Though Brazil tax import policies have been quite volatile throughout the 2012 fiscal year, it can be said with certainty that they lean towards protectionism rather than free-trade. Yet, Brazil has somehow managed to avoid complains in the WTO and project the image of a pro-liberal and free trade country; an image that its neighboring country, Argentina, has failed to project to the World.
With that in mind, why do both countries project such a different image to the world? Why do Brazil's trade policies are more accepted than Argentina's trade policies? After all, both policies attempt to reach the same goal: develop their own manufacturer industry.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)